I have tried ~10 liquid lipstick formulas and this one is in my top three. You can apply a nice thin layer and the color lasts well without cracking. Additionally, it dries down fully, so it doesn't transfer to coffee cups or water glasses. I love that these come in minis as I'll never use up a full size. I like the color selection, but the shades Sincere and Committed look almost the same. I ended up using Charming up entirely and the others dried up after ~1 year.